Specialist Vs Generalist: Which One Is Better?
Are you a generalist or specialist? A generalist is someone who knows a lot, but perhaps not as much in a narrow subject area. A specialist would know more about something specific and not much about other subjects.
Table of Contents
Neither is better, and context matters. Being good at one particular task makes you desirable because of the quality signals you broadcast. Being jake of all trade is beneficial as it allows you to handle many scenarios, especially in an unpredictable world.
Specialist Vs. Generalist
Do Quantity and Quality Finally Balance?
The job market presents us with either specialized or generalized opportunities. Depending on your career goals, you can choose to be a specialist or a generalist.
Most people will choose one over the other without carefully considering what each entails.
As career paths are not linear, whether to become a specialist or a generalist is of interest to many of us while thinking about careers.
So, should you become a specialist or a generalist? This is unfortunately not a straight answer question, so "it depends."
Do you want to be known for a particular area, or do you want to be knowledgeable in different areas? Do you look for career flexibility or a focused career?
Both generalist and specialist career routes have advantages and disadvantages.
Having a deep understanding of both is vital in knowing the path to take because both have pros and cons.
Let's delve into discussing the advantages of both specialization and generalization.
The term "generalist" refers to a person who has a broad range of skills and knowledge in his or her field. People with a more generalist career tend to have an interest in various subjects.
One of the reasons why some people become generalists is because of the career inflexibility as a specialist.
It is the ability to do multiple works, seeing the bigger picture, as opposed to a single specialty.
In the world of business, generalists have high value because they are often well-versed on a wide variety of topics and issues, allowing them to offer unique perspectives to any situation.
A generalist career could open various doors because of the wider career path. The career opportunities are broader in the sense that he or she can tap into various domains.
For instance, a generalist musician could both play piano, guitar or saxophone. The same way a generalist writer can write books on various topics.
Pros of Generalization
Ability to Market to a Larger Audience
As a generalist, you're able to market to a larger audience. This is because of the cheap charges that clients have to pay for services provided.
For example, midwives can reach out to more clients because it costs lesser to have their services than going for a gynecologist.
There are more services that a generalist can provide to clients compared to a specialist. Since they are more diverse, they are able to do more for their clients and find solutions beyond the scope of the work they are hired for.
For instance, a generalist teacher can teach more than one subject.
Capacity to Diversify Services
A generalist is able to offer diversified services because of having some basic knowledge about multiple subjects.
For example, an IT professional can offer IT support work as well as manage an IT project because of having diversified knowledge.
Clients Have Alternatives to Work With
Generalists offer clients alternatives in case what they want isn't available. Because of the fact that they can do more with the knowledge they have, they are able to give clients varied options.
Cons of Generalization
Inability to Do Specialized Jobs
Generalists don't have the ability to work in specialized jobs. Generalists can't do projects that require the expertise of a specialist. They don't have the skills and knowledge required to do a quality job.
For example, a general accounting professional cannot work on a project that requires expertise in actuarial science. They might risk missing vital information necessary for effective work.
Rates of Payment are Lower
The amount of money that clients pay for services done by a generalist is lower than that done by a specialist. If you would like to earn more for services offered, the best path to take is that of a specialist.
Lower Job Security
There is little job security for a generalist compared to a specialist. It is easier for a company to replace a generalist because they are many in the job market. If you are a generalist, you have to perform your work at the highest level because of the competition that exists.
When you are looking for the right career path to take, there are important questions you should ask yourself. One of these questions is whether you want to be a specialist or a generalist.
Both of these choices have advantages and disadvantages to consider. From this article, you're able to review the pros and cons of each and see where you fit the best.
Depending on the industry where you operate, you're able to tell whether you're better positioned as a specialist or a generalist.
Specialization is a process of narrowing the scope of your subject matter, typically to a specific area or aspect.
It refers to being an expert in a particular field—a narrowly defined job. Specialization is a way of dividing a field of knowledge into smaller and more manageable parts so that people with expertise in one area can focus their efforts on the most important problems in that area.
According to LinkedIn's findings, most of the fastest-growing jobs are for "specialist" positions. This is because people tend to contact specialists when faced with problems.
Specializing also allows a person to develop an expertise that other people need, which means he or she can make a living by providing services in that area.
It requires a narrowed focus to be able to deliver high-quality work in your area of work.
Pros of Specialization
Expertise in Area of Specialty
According to a 2021 research article by PLOS ONE, specialization gives one an upper advantage in a field of operation. Since you're focusing on one area, you're able to become an expert in that area.
Specialists tend to be very focused, which diminishes their skills in other areas of their profession.
Some clients like working with experts in a specialty because of the level of proficiency they portray. An example of such is a gastroenterologist who is an expert in treating disorders affecting the digestive system.
In this case, people with illnesses related to the digestive system are more likely and more comfortable seeing a specialist than a generalist. Another example is when someone is having issues with their employers. They would rather see a seasoned employment lawyer than any other lawyer.
A specialist career path is less broad than that of a generalist.
In-Depth Understanding of Work
Specialization is a product of one developing a thorough understanding of a specialty.
To become a specialist, you have to be vastly knowledgeable in a particular area. For example, a marketing specialist has comprehensive knowledge and understanding of the marketing field.
At the same time, the person could be specialized in SEO, for instance, and provide more value to customers interested in SEO services.
Clients Pay More
It is advantageous to work as a specialist because you'll be able to earn more. Their salaries tend to be higher compared to generalists'.
Typically, specialists charge more for their services because of the level of expertise and knowledge they possess.
For example, a pediatrician charges more than a general doctor for treatment, and the same goes for software engineers specializing in a specific field.
Streamlined Work Process
Specialists work in a more streamlined work environment. This means that there are fewer delays and errors.
Efficiency is high when a specialist does the work needed. A good example is a tax specialist. A tax specialist's work is more efficient than when an accountant does the same job.
Cons of Specialization
Risky When Economy Goes Down
When the economy goes down, it's risky working as a specialist because you'll lose clients.
For example, to save costs in a poor economy, a business can choose to work with a general IT practitioner instead of a cyber-security expert to keep its systems secure.
The job opportunities available to specialists are fewer than that of generalists.
Specialists don't work with everyone in a particular market, hence, limiting their reach. For example, a content writer specializing in finance doesn't attract clients from the accounting market segment.
Limited Capacity for Business Expansion
As a result of a specialist having a narrow market, there is limited capacity for business expansion. Lack of diversity hinders growth.
Risk of Obsoleteness
Some specialists are at risk of becoming obsolete because of emerging technology. According to a 2021 article by Forbes, a good example is network engineers. They are being replaced by automatic network management.
The Bottom Line
Hopefully, we can see that context matters, and none of them is better than the other. The most important thing is knowing how to position yourself in the job market and the kind of market you want to play in based on career prospects.
It would be helpful if you became a generalist first before you specialize, because this will give you the opportunity to discover what you actually want and can do better than most people. This is where you can thrive effortlessly.
Join the newsletter to receive the latest updates in your inbox.